Policyholder Triumphs in Machinery Damage Dispute

A recent decision in an Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) case has ruled in favour of a business seeking coverage for damage to machinery, despite the hiring company not adhering to all prescribed safety guidelines.

The matter involved a Winlet 575 Glass Robot that sustained damage when its stabiliser failed during operation.

The incident occurred in June 2017 when the glass handling machine tipped over while reversing. A representative from the involved business suggested that the machine's anti-crush functionality might have inadvertently been activated, causing it to lurch and topple under the load of a substantial glass sheet that measured 9.5 metres in height. Speed was also cited as a potential factor.

QBE, the insurer, initially rejected the claim based on assessments from the machine supplier's managing director and their own loss adjuster. These experts contended that the mishap was likely due to the glass panel being lifted off-centre and the boom being set too high during operation.

In contrast, the business's own glass specialist attributed the incident to operator error. Their argument highlighted the challenges in precisely aligning the lifting point with the panel's centre of gravity, particularly as it shifts when the machine rotates.

AFCA's ruling pointed out that, while the glass should normally be lifted at its centre of gravity, as per the machine's manual, the actual situation involved more complex dynamics. The authority found no definitive evidence that not adhering fully to these instructions directly led to the incident, and thus deemed the insurer's exclusion inapplicable. Furthermore, AFCA cast doubt on the supplier's MD's technical conclusions and his potential conflict of interest.

Ultimately, the decision underscores the importance of nuanced technical assessments in insurance disputes and calls for insurers to thoroughly investigate all claims aspects.

Looking forward, this ruling could influence future disputes where operational mishaps intersect with technical manual prescriptions, potentially prompting insurers to revisit their evaluation protocols and company guidance concerning machinery operation claims.

Published:Wednesday, 6th Aug 2025
Source: Paige Estritori

Share this news item:

Insurance News

Rising Group Premiums Pose Challenges for Australian Life Insurance

28 Aug 2025: Paige Estritori

Insurance premiums for group life policies with long-term benefits have surged between 15% to 25% on average in the first half of the year, according to a mid-year market update from Marsh Australia. While the steepest increases affected those with adverse claims experiences, short-term rates and premiums for permanent disabilities remained relatively steady. The sector has also become more selective, with insurers adopting stricter underwriting standards, particularly eschewing high-risk industries. - read more

Concerns Arise Over Construction Code Pause Amid Housing Push

28 Aug 2025: Paige Estritori

The federal government's initiative to accelerate housing development by relaxing certain building regulations has raised alarm within the insurance sector. Housing Minister Clare O’Neil announced changes on social media, indicating a strategic pause on parts of the National Construction Code to expedite building approvals and encourage the construction of much-needed homes across Australia. This move comes in response to challenges in the approval process, which often delays construction. - read more

RACQ Insurance Ordered to Increase Payout After Claim Handling Flaws

27 Aug 2025: Paige Estritori

RACQ Insurance has been instructed to bolster a payout to a customer following a ruling by the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA). The dispute arose after the insurer's handling of a house fire claim lodged by a woman in October 2023 was found lacking. The fire, initiated by scented candles, resulted in significant fire and smoke damage to her home. - read more

ASIC Review Puts Life Insurance Sector Under Scrutiny

26 Aug 2025: Paige Estritori

The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) has spotlighted significant shortcomings in the direct sale of life insurance products, urging the industry to reassess its sales practices. The recent review unearthed ongoing issues with remuneration structures, indicating that some insurers still link commissions to sales targets, potentially fostering aggressive sales tactics. The study further revealed a troubling rise in claims disputes, with reported cases more than doubling since 2018, raising concerns about the transparency and trustworthiness of these policies. - read more

Ombudsman Sides with Insurer on Imposed Excess Dispute

25 Aug 2025: Paige Estritori

A recent ruling by the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) has upheld an insurer's decision to impose an additional $2000 excess on a property policy, following a dispute raised by a policyholder over claims history impacts. - read more

Strata Insurance Articles

Understanding the Key Differences Between Strata Insurance and Home Insurance

Strata insurance is a specialized type of insurance designed to cover multi-unit properties like apartment buildings and townhouses. It protects the common property and the shared interests of all owners within the strata scheme, offering coverage for facilities like pools, gardens, and shared structures. - read more

What Does Strata Insurance Cover? A Comprehensive Breakdown

Strata insurance is a specialized insurance policy designed to cover common property in apartment buildings, townhouses, and other strata-titled developments. This type of insurance is crucial for both property owners and strata schemes, as it provides peace of mind in the face of potential risks. - read more

Is Strata Insurance Mandatory for Apartment Buildings? The Essential Guide for Owners

Strata insurance is a specialized type of insurance designed for properties that are divided into multiple units or lots, such as apartment buildings. It protects the entire building’s common property and the individual interests of the owners. This includes coverage for areas like hallways, gardens, and shared facilities. - read more

Step-by-Step Guide to Filing a Strata Insurance Claim in Australia

Strata insurance is a specialized form of insurance designed to protect the shared areas of a property, typically seen in apartment complexes or townhouses. It covers communal assets like hallways, gardens, and recreational facilities. This type of insurance is crucial for both property owners and managers, as it safeguards against potential risks and liabilities associated with shared living spaces. - read more

Strata Insurance Explained: What’s Not Covered and Why It Matters

Strata insurance is a type of cover designed specifically for properties that are subdivided into individual lots or units, which is common in residential and mixed-use developments. It protects the overall structure and shared areas of the property and is usually managed by a strata management body. This insurance is crucial not just for safeguarding the building itself but also for ensuring that common property, such as gardens, hallways, and balconies, is covered against a range of risks. - read more

Knowledgebase

Grace Period:
A time period after the premium is due during which an insurance policy remains in force even if the premium has not yet been paid.